American rental house pricing is currently erratic at best

July 29, 2011

Apartment for rent sign in Cincinnati, photo by The Cincy Project.

Houses versus apartments for rent

Often, when we analyze the rental market in America, we and other industry analysts typically lump multi-family in with houses for rent, but analyzed separately, they paint quite a different picture.

This week, we charted the apartment rental trends in the ten largest American cities which reveals that although rents are on the rise across all unit sizes, most increases are gradual. Apartment communities are increasingly using complex systems like Rent Roll to determine rents taking into account availability in their property along with comparable properties and their availability, amenities within each unit, time on market and the like.

Often, houses for rent rely on a comparative market analysis from the MLS which accounts for these same factors, but relies on a professional to discern these factors. Also, rents are set by homeowners who have a personal attachment to a home and a pride that complexes pricing, and ultimately the price is set by the homeowner.

Increasingly, homeowners are becoming “accidental landlords” as they rent out their home to cover their mortgage and move into a less expensive home in an effort to avoid foreclosure.

Advertise with The American Genius

Why rental house pricing is so erratic

Taking all of that into account, it is no wonder that rental trends for houses appear far less stable and predictable than apartments. There is no consistent national trend for houses, as many spiked in May, some are actually declining, while others are sharply increasing. In some cities, we are noticing a premium on larger apartments, most likely due to families losing their homes or becoming renters after selling a home to downsize.

Rentals are far more complex to analyze than residential sales, but take a look at the top ten largest cities and how house rents are performing on a local basis to get an idea of how it compares to your city.

Average house rents in New York City 
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in Los Angeles 
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in Chicago
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in Houston
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in Philadelphia
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in Phoenix
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in San Antonio
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in San Diego
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in Dallas
over the last 12 months

Average house rents in San Jose
over the last 12 months

Data source:

The future of computing The world gets caught up in the complexities of smartphones, tablets, augmented reality, scan technologies and the like, so it is nice to see Microsoft go back to the drawing board on an existing technology that so many people have opted to simply give up on…
There was a lot of spit-shining needed on the MLS and in local ads this week. It seems a lot of people cannot  spell in our native tongue.  Thanks to Jane Peters for her great contribution. Take a lick, uh, "look" at these: Lapping It Up "Be sure to lick up" (Rent a…

Lani is the Chief Operating Officer at The American Genius and sister news outlet, The Real Daily, and has been named in the Inman 100 Most Influential Real Estate Leaders several times, co-authored a book, founded BASHH and Austin Digital Jobs, and is a seasoned business writer and editorialist with a penchant for the irreverent.


  1. I recently read a news headline that declared rental prices are increasing across the country. Excited by the news, I check my local market in Los Angeles (Manhattan Beach), and was shocked to see that y-o-y median rents have fallen over 18%! Talk about erratic!

    As an economist I'm used to seeing more efficient markets and smooth price movements, not the kind of disjoint movements we're seeing in our rental market.

    I wonder if pricing tools will eventually work to smooth fluctuations, or if home owner landlords will continue to operate inefficiently?

Leave A Comment