Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

The American GeniusThe American Genius

Housing News

Reddit asks how to find a Realtor – answers reveals hidden advice for agents

“How do I find a good real estate agent?”

We monitor a lot of alternative spaces for real estate conversations to keep an accurate pulse on trends and we’ve noticed that naturally, in communities with little Realtor saturation, the answer and tone are very different than on websites like Trulia Answers.

This weekend, a Reddit user asked, “How do I find a good real estate agent? I am going to be buying a house in St. Paul, Minnesota and am trying to find a good real estate agent, but am having some difficulty. When I search for reviews online, the sites generally seem like they are made by real estate firms for advertising purposes. Any help would be appreciated.”

Tone of distrust, frustration

We’ll get to the answers but first we’d like to point you to the very question. Granted, this is a very web savvy community which is typically one peppered with disdain for corporations and companies not in the tech startup world, and is often wrought with condescension and cynicism. The question alone reveals many of those elements, but the automatic distrust is one you should note.

This isn’t a Star Trek convention goer wasting time online, this is a paying consumer that wants an agent and they’ve caught on to many ratings sites being commercial and gamed. Unlike the days of old where web users were trying to circumvent Realtors, consumers now are seeking agents but are lost in a sea of incomplete, possibly tampered with information.

The answers varied, but should be read in full because as an agent, you’re likely missing some places not only for lead generation but for the dreaded online reputation management.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Are you on Angie’s List?

For example, when was the last time you went to Angie’s List and searched for your name? It’s behind a wall and not indexed, so do you even have an account to know what’s going on behind closed doors? It could involve your name. This is by no means an endorsement of Angie’s List, I think it’s inappropriate that you have to pay to see reviews (although it makes sense to pay to write them). It is a loyal community, however, and is almost like the Yelp of service providers. It is the only recommendation the community gave that the home buyer responded to affirmatively- it seems their plan is to get on Angie’s List for their agent.

Other answers like blindly calling brokers

Other members of the community said “You are going to need to apply for a mortgage, so if you have a bank you prefer they can suggest a realtor in your area/price bracket.” The same member recommended searching Realtors’ websites in the desired price range and looking for repetition in agents among favored listings (which is a little misguided as buyer’s agents won’t always be named on a listing), blindly calling brokerages to test whoever is on “desk duty” to see if there is a match, real estate booklets, and driving around calling signs.

Despite the answers being jumbled and many being time intensive (aka time wasting) these all bode well for traditional agents, so perhaps even the most tech savvy of the tech savvy (average Reddit users) believe in being reached via traditional methods?

Other members pointed to, and a former agent left a rant about how busy agents that appear quality never call you back. It must be tough being a buyer and having to discern what is real, what is fake, and what is junk! Just this one question in this one point of time generated a lot of random answers and this is after the potential buyer is already frustrated and lacks trust in legitimacy of information they’re receiving online.

Realtor review sites

And what about the trend of real estate agent review sites? Most are so overwhelming to consumers that it looks like a paid pitch, or worse, a review written by a Realtor and subsequent reviews written by his adult children. Some are taking steps to minimize oversaturation like Mountain of Agents who has just opened up their allotment of zip codes but will only allow two agents per zip code for roughly $13 per month.

We reported on MoA at their launch and commended them for offering less subjective ratings criteria that appear to legitimately help a consumer. Zillow added Realtor ratings earlier this year to little fanfare and mixed ratings with a sentiment leaning toward dismissal at its inevitability.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The bottom line

There are many online sites that it could be beneficial for you as a Realtor to be aware of and even participate in that are seen as alternative. Maybe it’s worth budgeting some review sites into your marketing budget this year? Maybe it’s worth having an account on Angie’s List so you know what is being said about you and others?

Consumers are already nervous before they hit Google and when they get to one of the million options before them (search sites, agent sites, review sites, etc.), they’re already overwhelmed and then, they turn to their social networking community of choice for affirmation. If you’re in none of those places, is it akin to a tree falling in the woods?

Lani is the COO and News Director at The American Genius, has co-authored a book, co-founded BASHH, Austin Digital Jobs, Remote Digital Jobs, and is a seasoned business writer and editorialist with a penchant for the irreverent.



  1. Eric Hempler

    March 22, 2011 at 11:32 am

    This is what I did – I emailed the person and referred them to a great agent in St. Paul.

  2. Kevin "Troll" Tomlinson

    March 22, 2011 at 11:49 am

    First who is Reddit….didn’t they go out of biz, too?

    Opinions are like …..everyone’s got one.

  3. Teresa Boardman

    March 22, 2011 at 11:59 am

    I am not going to bite on this one. Go ahead and be outraged.

  4. Sara Bonert

    March 22, 2011 at 12:46 pm

    I recently moved out of state and tried to find a Realtor to help locate a rental for me – it was hard! Granted, I was looking for a Rental, I am sure response would have been better if I was looking for a For Sale home. I did not get a good response rate. I will say that reviews were a very valuable part of my search process, since I wasn’t calling specifically off homes on the market. I was looking for someone who would do a search for me and line up showings.

    Curious to as to why you say Zillow’s (disclosure: my employer) reviews were met to “little fanfare and mixed ratings”? We have over 25,000 on the site in about three months? To the best of my knowledge, while this number isn’t published on many sites, this is the largest database of agent specific reviews? I can say that there is a very notable difference in the amount of leads agents with reviews on the site receive verses those without any.

    • Benn Rosales

      March 23, 2011 at 11:22 pm

      Hi Sara,

      One word – fatigue.


      PS congrats on the 25k, although, I really don’t think anyone really has a choice but to play ball.

  5. Fred Romano

    March 22, 2011 at 2:02 pm

    Finding completely subjective ratings seems impossible. Plus, people love to “complain” online, but too often never post the “good” stuff.

  6. Doug Francis

    March 23, 2011 at 7:39 pm

    I wrote a similar post about this last week (no joke) since my clients have left comments all over. People are looking for good people and these “peer reviews” are exactly what has conditioned us to expect for virtually every purchase we make.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


American Genius
news neatly in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list for news sent straight to your email inbox.



Tech News

Over 32 million users are locked out of their Reddit communities following protests from recent API changes - let's talk about it.

Social Media

(Social Media) Reddit's UI hasn't always been super intuitive. 'Deck for Reddit' organizes your feed into themed columns, making it way more user-friendly.

Business News

WallStreetBets is back in the news for an unexpected reason - the founder is suing Reddit over trademark conflicts.

Business Marketing

With such a large, engaged user base, Reddit has a highly-sought-after advertising platform. With new updates, their Ad Manager is enticing.


The American Genius is a strong news voice in the entrepreneur and tech world, offering meaningful, concise insight into emerging technologies, the digital economy, best practices, and a shifting business culture. We refuse to publish fluff, and our readers rely on us for inspiring action. Copyright © 2005-2022, The American Genius, LLC.