Connect with us

Business News

Brokerage allegedly clones Estately’s multi-million dollar website

Intellectual property is a serious matter, particularly when it comes to product design and website code. One Canadian real estate group allegedly used Estately.com’s code on their own site, and Estately will “vigorously defend” their intellectual property.

Published

on

Estately’s intellectual property

Seattle based real estate search company, Estately.com intended to quietly handle what they allege to be Sutton WestCoast Realty’s intellectual property theft, having copied the code from Estately and using it for the design of their own website. Local tech writer, John Cook at GeekWire.com heard about the allegations and the issue was no longer a quiet problem held closely to the vest.

Galen Ward, CEO and Co-Founder of Estately told AGBeat that Estately has sent Sutton a cease and desist letter but has not heard back from the company, while GeekWire reports Sutton declines to comment but notes the issue is being handled by the company’s lawyers.

Ward said, “They copied the code that was live on Estately 3-4 months ago. They have changed a few words and they de-minified our javascript and CSS. That’s the extent of what has changed.”

Comparing the two sites

Below is a screenshot taken of Estately.com, followed by a screenshot of Sutton WestCoast Realty as captured by GeekWire.com, click either to enlarge.


Spotting the differences

Ward said, “We’ve spent millions of dollars developing Estately. Having a clone that is using our copyrighted works in Vancouver (that could grow elsewhere) will materially impact the valuation of the company and our ability to raise money, and would make opening Estately in Vancouver – a market that would be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars a year in revenues – a non-starter.”

Estately has received funding and even participated in the 500 Startups incubator program in 2010 and says that while they have had competitors copy individual features and design concepts, they have never before had a “wholesale copying of our functionality and codebase.”

Although Estately indicates they hope to resolve this outside of the court system, Ward said, “We will do whatever it takes to defend our copyright – including suing if necessary,” adding, “We are vigorously defending our [intellectual property] IP.”

As of publication, the search function on the Sutton WestCoast Realty website appears as follows for all attempts at searching the site:

The American Genius is news, insights, tools, and inspiration for business owners and professionals. AG condenses information on technology, business, social media, startups, economics and more, so you don’t have to.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
11 Comments

11 Comments

  1. Jeff Burke

    April 5, 2012 at 11:30 pm

    I could ask all kinds of questions concerning this issue. It seems to me that it would be a challenge to prove one copied anothers map search unless you could PROVE they lifted the code. Once something is in the public domain it seems to all change. Are Estately’s screens patented? Is that even possible? I am not an IP attorney so I have no idea.

    I do know that I am a startup in the exact same space and we try to improve on everything that is currently in the public domain. There are some innovative ideas on how to create a map search but I presume if they aren’t patented they are fair game to replicate.

    The screen shots are obviously similar but how different is any map search from the next? What influenced or inspired the map that Estately uses? Did they ever look at Zillow, Trulia or Redfin? Heck, I have never even heard of these guys much less seen their maps and I’ll tell you right now that our beta map search which is already well into development resembles them both. There are only so many ways to do basic map search.

    I’m not sure about the ability to accuse someone of stealing the code unless there is something more to this story than meets the eye. Did any of the coders do work for both companies? Was there a relationship bn the two companies that went south?

    Lots of questions…

    • Jeff Burke

      April 6, 2012 at 12:23 am

      Yuk…this stinks. As noted in last paragraph of previous post, there does seem to be a previous relationship of 3 years according to other sources and if that is the case I hope Estately buries these guys! Zero tolerance for this type of activity, especially if it originated from a working relationship.

    • Galen

      April 6, 2012 at 3:22 pm

      Jeff, this is a copyright and IP concern, not patents.

      Make beautiful map search interfaces, just don’t copy our code or use our code as your starting point.

      • Jeff Burke

        April 6, 2012 at 6:23 pm

        I rescind any previous question of doubt and hope you guys can prove it up. That is wrong on so many levels. It has happened to me before and I hope you guys get your day! Best of luck!

  2. Kevin Lisota

    April 6, 2012 at 2:18 am

    Jeff,

    Sutton had a contract to use Estately for 3 years. At the end of the 3 years, they lifted icons/css/js/html directly to create a clone. There is no question of the theft here. If you looked at the underlying code, most of it was identical.

    We had a similar relationship with Estately that disallowed reverse engineering and derivative works. Clearly this was a derivative work, which is probably why the site has now been down for over a day.

    • Jeff Burke

      April 6, 2012 at 6:21 pm

      That is SO jacked up! I hope they can prove it and are able to prosecute to the fullest extent.

  3. Larry

    April 6, 2012 at 2:36 pm

    Well this is probably one case of the DMCA coming in handy.

  4. RossK

    April 7, 2012 at 9:17 am

    Are you guys serious or is this an april fools post.

    This is a common idx template that is already available for FREE to anyone. This exact same template is used on hundreds of sites.

    And…if anyone wants to start discussing copyrights and IP lets start talking about such thefts in the current syndication process.

    I own the copyright on every listing I create and publish. The MLS does not own that copyright.

    Now call your attorneys.

    • Alex Cortez

      April 9, 2012 at 5:11 pm

      Ross, when you input your listing on your local MLS, do you NOT agree to have it syndicated?

      You said that you ‘own the copyright on every listing I create and publish’. Since you feel your ‘copyright’ is being infringed upon, perhaps it’s time YOU call your attorney

  5. Josh Nekrep

    May 10, 2012 at 6:32 pm

    I don’t know any of the details here, but it wouldn’t surprise me if it was the case that those who commissioned the “copy” site weren’t technical enough to recognize the error of their ways. They’ll blame it on the web developer, and the web developer will say they were only doing what was asked of them. There’s bound to be a lot of playing dumb when/if this makes its way to court, and likely nothing substantial will come of it other than the fact that it will remain down and they’ll come out with a new site.

  6. Ken Granger

    May 10, 2012 at 6:32 pm

    No reputable web developer should ever copy another sites work even if instructed by their client to do so. You might get some hack, or over seas company to do that, but a legit web company knows better.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Business News

How remote work has changed over the last decade

(BUSINESS NEWS) let’s reflect on how remote working and telecommuting has changed in recent years and look to how it will continue to change in the 2020s.

Published

on

remote at home

As someone who often works remote, it’s interesting to see how much that means for work has evolved. The increase in commonality has been steady, and shows no signs of slowing down. Go Remotely has developed an insightful graphic showing the changes in trends regarding remote work over the years.

“For decades, the established economy dictated that you should pick one job, visit the same office for the next 40 years, and then retire,” reads the graphic’s intro. “However, recent remote working stats suggest the working world might be in for some revolutionary changes.”

From there, the graphic is broken down into five facets: Flexible Workspace Policy, Entrepreneurial Minds, Telecommuting is a Growing Trend, The Role of Companies in the Remote Working World, and The Future of Telecommuting.

With Flexible Workspace Policy, its suggested that telecommuting could be a solution for costly issues including lack of productivity caused by employee distractions, health problems, etc. It is said that employers lose $1.8 trillion annually due to these issues.

The end of 2018 found 35 percent of the US workforce working remotely. This is only expected to climb. Ten percent of employees don’t know if their company offers flexible work policies (this is something to check into!)

Bills and laws for virtual jobs passed by governments reflect the need for accessibility, economic stability, and emigration concerns. Companies with flexible work policies have reported seeing increases in productivity and profits. (Funny those both start with pro, no?)

With Entrepreneurial Minds, a few interesting things found include: remote workers are less likely to take off if they are sick, the majority reports better productivity when working alone, the majority reported lower stress levels. However, there is a problem with not being able to unplug after work which is an issue for some.

Telecommuting is a Growing Trend finds that there has been a seven percent increase between 2012 and 2016, with the majority (80-100 percent) reporting they work remotely. Industries seen embracing remote work include: transportation, computer/information systems/mathematical, arts/design/entertainment/sports/media, finance/insurance/real estate, law or public policy, community/social services, science/engineering/architecture, manufacturing or construction, healthcare, education/training/library, and retail.

The Role of Companies in the Remote Working World finds that the pros to hiring remote workers includes: finding talent outside of your geographic area, improves retention on work/life balance, increases productivity by decreasing commute time, and saves money by requiring less office space. The cons include lack of timeliness when it comes to receiving information from employers.

Finally, the Future of Telecommuting suggests that in 2020 the US mobile worker population will surpass 105 million (and will account for 72 percent of the US workforce). Hiring managers predict that telecommuting will increase tremendously, most skills will become even more niche over the next decade, and many think that 38 percent of their full-time workers will be working remotely in the next decade.

How do you feel about the increase in remote working and telecommuting?

Continue Reading

Business News

ClickUp team productivity app is gorgeous and wildly efficient

(BUSINESS NEWS) Seeking to improve your productivity and speed up your team, ClickUp is an inexpensive option for those obsessed with efficiency.

Published

on

clickup

Back again to obsess over productivity apps – ClickUp, is a project management tool seeking to knock the frustration out of PM. It’s getting some good reviews, so I gave it a try for a week by setting up my current job search as a project and getting a feel for the app. And as you’ve read in my other reviews, we will address features and design.

On the feature front, ClickUp offers a pretty standard set up of tools for a productivity app. What stands out first and foremost are the status options. In general, most productivity statuses are simple: not started, started, in progress, done, etc.

But ClickUp lets you set up custom statuses that match your workflow.

For example, if you’re doing instructional design projects, you may assign projects based on where they are flowing in an ADDIE model, or if you are a Realtor, you may have things cataloged by sold, in negotiation, etc.

Customization is king and custom status is the closest you get to building your own app. And if you like it simple, you don’t have to customize it. The assigned comments feature lets you follow up on specific comments that originate action items – which is useful in team collaborations.

You can also assign changes to multiple tasks at once, including changing statuses (I would bulk assign completion tasks when I finished applications that I did in batches). There a lot of features here, but the best feature is how the app allows you to toggle on and off features that you will or won’t use – once again, customization is front and center for this platform.

In terms of design and intuive use, ClickUp nailed it.

It’s super easy to use, and the concept of space is pretty standard in design thinking. If your organization uses Agile methodology, this app is ready for you.

In terms of view, you can declutter the features, but the three viewing modes (list, box, and board) can help you filter the information and make decisions quickly depending on what role you have on a board or project. There is also a “Me” board that removes all the clutter and focuses on your tasks – a great way to do focused productivity bursts. ClickUp describes itself as beautifully intuitive, and I can’t disagree – both the web app and mobile app are insanely easy to use.

No complaints here.

And the horizon looks good for ClickUp – with new features like image markup, Gannt charts (!!!!!! #nerdalert), and threaded comments for starts.

This application is great, and it’s got a lot of growth coming up to an already rich feature base. It’s free with 100MB of storage, but the $5 fee for team member per month that includes team onboarding and set up (say you’re switching from another platform) and Dropbox/Google Docs integration? That’s a bargain, Charlie.

ClickUp is on the way up and it’s got it all – features, a beautifully accessible UI, relentless customization, and lot of new and upcoming features. If you’re into the productivity platform and you’re looking for a new solution for your team, go check it out.

Continue Reading

Business News

Should you alter your business travel due to the Coronavirus?

(BUSINESS NEWS) Got a business trip coming up? Worried about the coronavirus spoiling those plans? Stay up to date and safe with this cool site!

Published

on

travel coronavirus

The Center for Systems Science and Engineering (CSSE) at John Hopkins University has created a website that tracks one of the biggest trends of 2020: the coronavirus. Also known as 2019-nCoV, this disease has already spread to over 40,000 confirmed cases worldwide, with over 900 deaths (as of when this article was published, anyway.)

Not to mention, the United States Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) notes that we still don’t know exactly how the virus spreads from person-to-person. In fact, there’s quite a bit we don’t know about this disease and although some people are reported as recovered, it’s only a small fraction compared to how many are sick.

So, what’s so great about this tracker? Well, first of all, it updates in real time, making it easy to keep track of everything we know about confirmed cases of the coronavirus. It’s chock full of statistics and visuals, making the information easy to digest. Plus, with a map front and center, it lets you know exactly where there have been reported outbreaks – and how many people have been diagnosed.

Because the site sticks to cold hard facts like statistics and maps, it also means you can avoid the racism and general panic that’s accompanied news of this outbreak.

This is a great tool for staying informed, but it’s also extremely helpful if you’re going to be traveling for work. As the virus continues to progress, you’ll be able to see just how many cases of coronavirus there are in the areas you’re planning to visit, which will allow you to plan accordingly. Even if you don’t feel the effects, you can still risk passing it to other people.

(In fact, the CDC recommends those traveling from certain areas in China practice “social distancing” when they return to the US, avoiding public spaces like grocery stores, malls and movie theaters.)

Of course, if you have something planned several months from now, don’t cancel your conference plans just yet. A lot can happen in that amount of time, so avoid the urge to check the website every couple hours. It’s supposed to be a tool for staying informed, not staying stressed out.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Our Great Partners

The
American Genius
news neatly in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list for news sent straight to your email inbox.

Emerging Stories

Get The American Genius
neatly in your inbox

Subscribe to get business and tech updates, breaking stories, and more!