Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

The American GeniusThe American Genius

Business News

Facebook in more trouble for favoring foreign workers on visa

(BUSINESS NEWS) Facebook has continued to be in hot water this year – this time getting sued by the DOJ for discrimination of American workers in favor of visa workers.

Visa employee on a laptop looking out the window.

While the latest big news on the US government vs Facebook front is the Dec. 9 antitrust suits that target the social media giant’s acquisition of Instagram and WhatsApp, just a week earlier the big news was an attack from another flank. On Dec. 3 the Department of Justice accused Facebook of discriminating against U.S. citizens in favor of hiring foreign workers on visa.

Let’s just say business groups, especially in tech, are not happy about this. The D.O.J.’s lawsuit could have a huge impact on the tech industry, which has long relied on hiring foreign workers who have temporary work visas that they can later convert to permanent visas (aka, green cards).

Here’s what you need to know.

Why did D.O.J. sue Facebook?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

D.O.J. says it’s protecting American and other authorized workers against discrimination and trying to save American jobs.

According to the press release: “Facebook intentionally created a hiring system in which it denied qualified U.S. workers a fair opportunity to learn about and apply for jobs that Facebook instead sought to channel to temporary visa holders Facebook wanted to sponsor for green cards.”

What is Facebook’s response?

“Facebook has been cooperating with the D.O.J. in its review of this issue, and while we dispute the allegations in the complaint, we cannot comment further on pending litigation,” said Facebook spokesman Andy Stone.

How did Facebook allegedly discriminate?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The D.O.J. says that, from January, 2018, to September, 2019, Facebook used special recruiting methods that in effect reserved more than 2,600 jobs for foreign workers who hold temporary work visas, mostly H-1Bs. The suit alleges that jobs were posted only in print outlets, not on Facebook’s careers website, which would cast a wider net. Also, applicants had to apply by mail, not online like for other jobs – both of which created a pool of pre-selected candidates based on immigration status.

So the allegation is that Americans couldn’t apply for jobs they didn’t know about, which let Facebook effectively game the system by meeting the legal requirements of posting jobs and saying that no or few qualified U.S. citizens applied – meaning they could keep employees who had already been working there for between 3 and 6 years.

Why is this illegal?

The D.O.J. says Facebook violated the Immigration and Nationality Act, which “prohibits employers from discriminating against U.S. citizens and other work-authorized individuals
based on their citizenship status or national origin.”

What does the lawsuit ask for?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The suit asks for “civil penalties” (aka, money), back pay for U.S. workers who were denied employment because of the alleged discrimination, and changes to Facebook’s hiring procedures. (One thing that’s not clear is which U.S. workers would be included in back pay and how they would show they lost out on a job they didn’t know about.)

What’s behind the suit?

Short answer: It probably depends on your politics.

It could be part of the Trump administration’s continuing attack on immigration. It could be “techlash,” part of the Trump administration’s continuing attacks on social media giants. Or it could be the Trump administration’s fight to save jobs for Americans in a time of high unemployment, as well as to prevent companies from taking advantage of relatively cheap labor that depresses wages for U.S. citizens.

How does the work visa system work?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Most temporary work visas come through the H-1B system, but there are also H-2A, H-2B, and F-1 visas. After an employee has been in the job 3 years, the employer can ask for the temporary visa to convert to a green card, which makes the holder a permanent lawful resident. However, employers must demonstrate that they were not able to find qualified U.S. workers.

The H-1B visa program has been embroiled in an ongoing battle this year, with President Trump attempting to impose bans, caps, and new restrictions and courts knocking down those attempts. So things like how many visas are awarded, how workers are chosen, and regulations on minimum salaries and education levels designed to allow only higher-skilled workers – that all could change seemingly at any time. (Check out Investopedia for a fuller explanation of the ins and outs.)

What’s next?

Who knows? It’s wait and see on whether the new administration of President-Elect Joe Biden will address the lawsuit, although he has pledged to undo Trump’s immigration policies.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Lisa Wyatt Roe is an Austin writer and editor whose work has been featured on CNN.com/Travel, in Texas Parks & Wildlife Magazine and in the book “Seduced by Sound: Austin; 100 Musicians on Why They Make Music.” Travel and live music feed her soul. Volunteering with refugees feeds her sense of purpose. And making friends laugh feeds her deep (yet possibly sad) need to get all the laughing emojis on Facebook.

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. jake leone

    December 14, 2020 at 3:31 pm

    Your readers need to understand that Facebook found hundreds of qualified Local-American applicants for much tougher tech jobs. Facebook refused to forward these better qualified Americans to the managers who were hiring the foreign workers, they did this exclusion deliberately. And that is why this is a clear case of discrimination based upon National Origin.

    Facebook lied on Federal Forms when it said it made a good faith effort, Facebook make a bad faith effort. And we know this because, facebook refused the San Francisco Chronicle’s FREE offer to post these jobs on the Chronicle website (all Facebook had to do was say “yes” instead of “no”), at the time the Chronicle was posting the jobs in print. And also, as you have pointed out, Facebook has extensive public company job board, but Facebook never put these jobs on that board.

    This FAKE/PERM process is well documented, and is quite scandalous. We need to fix the PERM process before we talk about getting rid of the diversity of the Green Card system. Mike Lee’s bill is a massive dentriment and clearly a give away to the absolutely bigoted hiring practices of companies in Silicon Valley. Fix the PERM process, and you will fix the Green Card back log very quickly, and more Americans will be able to get into a tech job. Again, Facebook had hundreds of qualified candidates, that it could not hire, into much tougher tech positions than the ones that were involved in these FAKE/PERM jobs.

    The big lie that tech companies can’t find qualified workers is fully exposed in this government indictment. Facebook was cooperating but has since gone silent. Cleary, this didn’t fully register what the implications of this massive fraud would be, otherwise I think they would not have cooperated with the government. Now that they have, it is too late. And civil lawsuits will follow.

    The process that Facebook gamed is called the PERM process. The PERM process can be redone, every 6 months, until the employers luck out (or deliberately avoid looking as is the case with FACEBOOK) and say (really lie) on Federal forms they couldn’t find an American.

    Literally, if an employer over a 10 year period, found plenty of qualified Americans to fill the foreign workers position, the employer can still refuse to hire an American. Because the foreign worker is allowed to renew their H-1b visa, indefinitely while doing the PERM process (in this case repeating the PERM process 2x a year, for 10 years).

    Meaning, that there is no actual equality in the hiring process when employers undergo PERM process for a foreign worker. The foreign worker can literally displace a better qualified American for a job on U.S. soil, forever.

    And Facebook has already been shown to do this, 2600+ times, over less than a 2-year period, covered by this investigation. Read the indictment, it’s online.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

AdBlocker Message

Our website is kept FREE to you by displaying online ads to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker OR subscribing to our email newsletter: https://theamericangenius.com/get-american-genius-newsletter/

The
American Genius
news neatly in your inbox

Subscribe to our mailing list for news sent straight to your email inbox.

Advertisement

KEEP READING!

Tech News

Two powerhouse companies in the social media and delivery space team up to deliver online sold goods right to the buyer's door.

Business Marketing

Facebook announced that they are shutting down their live shopping feature in a move to focus more on Reels on October 1, however, it...

Social Media

New data indicates that influencer marketing is much more lucrative on Instagram and TikTok than Facebook - where will *your* 2023 ad spend go?

Business News

Apparently, Facebook launched a podcast program almost a year ago, but it was short-lived as Zuckerberg pulls the plug 10-months in.

The American Genius is a strong news voice in the entrepreneur and tech world, offering meaningful, concise insight into emerging technologies, the digital economy, best practices, and a shifting business culture. We refuse to publish fluff, and our readers rely on us for inspiring action. Copyright © 2005-2022, The American Genius, LLC.