Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

The American Genius Real EstateThe American Genius Real Estate

Real Estate Corporate

Zestimate suit brings a spot of good news to Zillow’s legal department

(CORPORATE NEWS) Zillow has been making news headlines for a myriad of reasons. This time it is a spot of good news for them.

zillow patent grab

Zillow wins

U.S. District Court Judge Amy St. Eve dismissed the class-action lawsuit filed in May against Zillow. The lawsuit alleged Zillow’s Zestimate tool misled potential homebuyers into believing the Zestimates were actual, accurate appraisals.

bar
Judge Amy St. Eve stated, Zillow’s Zestimates “are not likely to confuse potential homebuyers as they are simply a ‘starting point’ for home buying research.”

The lawsuit

In June, our own Connor Wrenn, covered the contest Zillow held to fix Zestimates’ algorithm. This makes you wonder just how Zillow escaped the lawsuit, considering the suit alleged that Zestimates injured home sellers and builders because it listed properties with lower values than the asking price (hinting the algorithm was faulty and shortly thereafter, Zillow is holding a contest to fix said algorithm).

Judge St. Eve hints the reason is because Zillow states on their website that Zestimates are not necessarily accurate – which seems like quite the understatement.

Zillow’s side

Zillow has previously stated their algorithm “isn’t perfect.” Zestimates are within 5% of the actual sale price approximately 54% of the time; within 10% of the actual sale price approximately 76% of the time; and within 20% of the actual sale price approximately 90% of the time according to the lawsuit.

What about the rest of the claims?

What about the part that states Zillow’s practice is listing home values based on Zestimates’ algorithm was fraudulent since the company isn’t a licensed appraiser.

Under Illinois state law, it’s indeed illegal to offer an appraisal without a state license to do so.

However, Zillow was prepared for this allegation and stated that there is a section of the same law that allows “automated variations.” Judge St. Eve obviously agreed as she wrote, “the word ‘Zestimate’ – an obvious portmanteau of ‘Zillow’ and ‘estimate’ – itself indicates that Zestimates are merely an estimate of the market value of a property.”

On the brightside

On a positive note, however, the judge stated the plaintiffs would be allowed to re-plead three of the four claims:

  1. The claim that Zillow violated homeowners’ privacy by placing their homes on its site without their permission.
  2. Plaintiffs seek an injunction for costs and attorney fees under Illinois Uniform Deceptive Trade Practices Act (IDTPA).
  3. Plaintiffs seek damages, costs, punitive damages, and attorney fees based on the violation of the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act (ICFA).

Questions, comments, concerns

What do you think about the ruling? Do you agree with judge St. Eve, or do you think what Zillow is doing is unfair?

#Zillow

Jennifer Walpole is a Senior Staff Writer at The American Genius and holds a Master's degree in English from the University of Oklahoma. She is a science fiction fanatic and enjoys writing way more than she should. She dreams of being a screenwriter and seeing her work on the big screen in Hollywood one day.

Advertisement

The Daily Intel
in your inbox

Subscribe and get news and EXCLUSIVE content to your email inbox.

Advertisement

KEEP READING!

Real Estate Corporate

Is Opendoor and Zillow's simple team up worth any of the hype or critique it's getting? Let's examine the partnership.

Real Estate Technology

Is Zillow building a future patent trolling practice? They put in patent applications for online ads & data-based algorithms...WHAT?!

Real Estate Brokerage

(REAL ESTATE NEWS) REX Homes filed an anti-trust lawsuit against NAR and Zillow in 2021. Now, NAR is hitting back with a spicy countersuit....

Real Estate Corporate

(TECHNOLOGY) In yet another broad patent application, Zillow is aiming for ownership of the ability to fill out “transactional documents” electronically.

The American Genius' real estate section is honest, up to the minute real estate industry news crafted for industry practitioners - we cut through the pay-to-play news fluff to bring you what's happening behind closed doors, what's meaningful to your practice, and what to expect in the future. We're your competitive advantage. The American Genius, LLC Copyright © 2005-2022